Avatar
All Posts by Empower Wisconsin

Congressional Action Is the Best Way to Fix Qualified Immunity

Empower Wisconsin | June 3, 2020

By Robert Verbruggen, National Review 

As cities across the country descend into chaos in response to a clear case of police misconduct, there’s a lot of pressure on the Supreme Court to reconsider a doctrine known as “qualified immunity.”

Under federal law, police officers who infringe on civilians’ constitutional rights can be sued in federal court, but the qualified-immunity doctrine shields them from such suits unless their actions violated “clearly established law.” In other words, plaintiffs have to show not only that their rights were violated, but also that the officer’s conduct had been addressed in similar previous cases and found to be unconstitutional. If no previous case involving the disputed conduct exists, as often happens because each case is unique, the officer is immune.

The Court has been reluctant to reconsider this doctrine, but it’s currently mulling whether to hear several relevant cases. These cases could have huge ramifications, because qualified immunity had come under intense fire for the last several years, starting long before the death of George Floyd. Many legal scholars say the doctrine should go entirely. And at minimum, it’s clear from a string of incidents in which courts gave cops immunity despite flagrant wrongdoing that the rule needs reform.

The Court should take up this matter. But it should not have the final word. Going forward, Congress should rewrite the law at issue to resolve the countless problems that have arisen from it in the 150 years since it was passed. The fair treatment of both civilians and police officers is at stake, and only Congress can reform qualified immunity in a way that fully addresses our current situation and concerns. Courts are limited to applying the law as it currently exists, and we need more than that right now.

Read more at National Review.

Listen to more:

Explore More
Trump campaign sues Wisconsin elections officials

Trump campaign sues Wisconsin elections officials

President Trump’s campaign filed a lawsuit Tuesday in the Wisconsin Supreme Court seeking to toss out what it claims are more than 220,000 invalid ballots cast in the Badger State’s two biggest — and most liberal — counties. 

Read More »

December 2, 2020
Will Evers cost Wisconsin millions?

Will Evers cost Wisconsin millions?

As the clock winds down on 2020, Republican lawmakers are growing increasingly concerned the Evers administration will cost the state hundreds of millions of dollars in lost federal funding. 

Read More »

December 2, 2020
China’s pandemic deception

China’s pandemic deception

On the menu today: sorting through CNN’s fascinating but not completely illuminating bombshell involving leaked documents from the Hubei, China Center for Disease Control and Prevention, filling in some details about the early days of the pandemic.

Read More »

December 2, 2020
‘Autonomous zone’ bar 

‘Autonomous zone’ bar 

Keith McAlarney told Tucker Carlson this week New York’s big government leaders have pushed his back against the wall with their business-killing COVID-19 mandates. It was either buck the orders or go out of business. 

Read More »

December 2, 2020
Health order fines for Thanksgiving

Health order fines for Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving week came with a side of public health fines for Dane County businesses, as Public Health Madison & Dane County clamps down on public gatherings in the COVID-19 era.

Read More »

December 1, 2020
Eyewitness to Milwaukee election fraud?

Eyewitness to Milwaukee election fraud?

Milwaukee County elections officials and their liberal allies insist there was no voter fraud in the presidential election. Witnesses to the Election Day ballot count say what they saw disputes those assertions. 

Read More »

December 1, 2020
Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *