Avatar
All Posts by Empower Wisconsin

Evers’ Order #12: Deciding what’s ‘essential’

Empower Wisconsin | March 25, 2020

By M.D. Kittle

John Stocks just wants the opportunity to say goodbye to his dying father.

That’s no longer possible under Gov. Tony Evers’ Emergency Order #12, his so-called “Safer At Home” edict now requiring most Wisconsin residents to shelter in place for the next month. Evers, too, has decided who is essential — and who isn’t —in the workforce and in the greater business community.

His coronavirus laws, which come with a $250 fine and jail time for “violators,” demand greater social distancing ostensibly for the greater good. That means people in their final days of life, like John Stocks’ father, face the grim prospect of dying alone, or at least without their loved ones beside them. Even their funerals in this new COVID-19 reality must take place with no more than a few family members or friends gathered.

Stocks shared his story Monday on the Vicki McKenna Show on NewsTalk 1310 WIBA.

“Other families in (the Intensive Care Unit) are going through the same ordeal, cancer patients are going through this ordeal,” said Stocks, whose dad is in the end stages of esophageal cancer. He’s been in intensive care for 85 days, admitted on New Year’s Day. The hospital wouldn’t allow Stocks, his brother, his sister, not even his mother into see the dying man. Health care officials finally relented and allowed his mother two hours to say her goodbyes.

“Until you’ve been in that situation, you don’t realize how much your support does impact how they get better, and how they pass,” Stocks said. “We can’t even have a funeral for my father. As his first-born son, I’m not there to be by his side. I had to say my goodbyes on Thursday.”

Stocks doesn’t blame the medical staff who have been so good to his father during his last battle. And he understands the urgent need to stop the spread of COVID-19, particularly in hospitals and nursing homes.

Still, it all feels very unfair.

Remarkable times, these. In the face of a very real health care crisis, Wisconsin’s governor wields a lot of power — some of it understandable, some of it questionable, some of it dangerous to our dearest-held American principles.

Evers justifies his new, broader order by pointing to the exigent circumstances, noting that in the past 72 hours the number of novel coronavirus cases soared 119 percent nationally; 102 percent in Wisconsin (from 206 to 416).

“Five Wisconsinites have passed away as a result of COVID-19. Public health officials estimate that the actual number of Wisconsinites infected with COVID-19 is significantly higher and likely present in every county in the state…” Evers edict proclaims.

Therefore,

“All individuals present within the State of Wisconsin are ordered to stay at home or at their place of residence” between 8 a.m. today and 8 a.m., April 24. A full month. He allows grocery shopping, seeing the doctor, and picking up medicine. You can walk your dog or exercise outside, but if you do any of those things, you’d better be at least six feet apart from the closest human being.

The homeless are exempt, but “strongly urged to obtain shelter.”

And all for-profit and non-profit businesses in the Badger State, except the ones the governor and his administration deem “essential,” are required to “cease all activities.”

What’s essential? What isn’t? Evers’ order includes a long list of necessary businesses and employees.

Those employed in frontline health care, defense, law enforcement, homeland security, critical infrastructure (you get the idea) will continue to operate. So will grocery stores, pharmacies, agriculture, transport companies and producers of food and beverage.

Child care providers, some charitable and social service organizations, gas stations, financial institutions, and post offices and other shippers of packages are considered essential. So, too, are laundry services, and suppliers to businesses and Wisconsin’s rapidly expanding at-home workforce.

While Evers and his administration have been anything but models of open government and protecters of the First Amendment, they do believe newspapers, television, radio and “other media services” are important enough to rank as essential.

Interestingly, the governor insists the “critical trades,” including building and construction tradespeople such as plumbers, electricians, carpenters, laborers, iron workers and fabricators are essential. Arguably so, but might his decision have anything to do with the outsized political support he’s received from labor unions?

More so, Evers order demands that “critical labor union functions,” including “administration of health and welfare funds” to members are essential.

Restaurants and bars are deemed essential, but they may only operate if they serve takeout food and beverages, or deliver.

Even sadder, the order’s recognition that places of worship and funeral homes are essential but prohibited from hosting life’s most important rites of passage. In short, weddings, funerals, and religious gatherings must be limited to no more than nine people “in a room or confined space at a time and individuals shall adhere to Social Distancing Requirements as much as possible.”

Graduation ceremonies, weddings, anniversary parties, baptisms, first communions, Easter egg hunts, events planned months, even years in advance, postponed or canceled. Life on hold.

So much at stake, so much to lose.

Stocks said he’s lost the final moments of his “hero’s life.”

“We don’t want my father to pass alone,” he said.

Listen to more:

Explore More
Evers busted in unemployment blame game

Evers busted in unemployment blame game

While Democrat Gov. Tony Evers blames Republican lawmakers for failing to upgrade the state’s Unemployment Insurance information technology system, the co-chairs of the Legislature’s Joint Finance Committee say the administration has long had the power to begin fixing the IT system. 

Read More »

January 26, 2021
Wisconsin Guard members back home from D.C.

Wisconsin Guard members back home from D.C.

Hundreds of Wisconsin National Guard soldiers and airmen are back home after a week of securing the Nation’s Capital in the days before and after the presidential inauguration. 

Read More »

January 26, 2021
Fauci highest-paid federal employee

Fauci highest-paid federal employee

Dr. Anthony Fauci raked in $417,608 in compensation from the federal government in 2019, putting the nation’s infectious disease expert at the top of the income chart above the rest of its 4 million federal employees, Forbes Magazine reported Monday.

Read More »

January 26, 2021
Eating COVID politics

Eating COVID politics

Several mayors and governors of U.S. blue cities and states are suddenly lifting restrictions on indoor dining at bars and restaurants. What changed? 

Read More »

January 26, 2021
Leave it to Evers: Profiles in incompetence

Leave it to Evers: Profiles in incompetence

Need a laugh? Sure, we all could use a chuckle these dark days. The Washington Post … No, that’s not the punchline yet. 

Read More »

January 25, 2021
4th-grade teacher gives students lesson in Trump-hating

4th-grade teacher gives students lesson in Trump-hating

An Oconto Falls Elementary school teacher told his 4th-grade students that he hopes President Donald Trump will never be president again and that the former president should be “impeached by the Senate,” according to video obtained by Empower Wisconsin.

Read More »

January 25, 2021

5 thoughts on “Evers’ Order #12: Deciding what’s ‘essential’

  • Draconian measures, no matter the source, need to be challenged in court (even If the court is not considered “essential” anymore) on each point – Ever’s decision needs to be reviewed by more intelligent and considerate people. His grab for power needs to end and his ability to makes such decisions needs to be limited.

  • I wonder is Evers playing pickle ball during this outbreak while golfers can’t play golf outside. How come our wonderful newspeople who keep us informed haven’t investigated that?

  • I commented earlier. Just adding a fact. I was in the ER at SCRMC on Sunday evening after presenting so.e symptoms of Covid 19. Influenza A and B and strept throat was ruled out. I was sent home as a possible Covid 19 case. I have to wear a mask in my own home. (I have to re-use the same one the entire time) I am quarantined for 7 days. My family in the house for 14 days. I cant have a test for coronavirus unless I am hospitalized because of the shortage of testing swabs. I may have infected many people. I may have the antibodies needed for the cure. How will we know?

  • The paper can be read On line. The Inter County Leader in Frederic says its essential. My husband and father to our children and foster children is essential. The paper can be done from home and read on line. He works close to at least a dozen people inside a building with about 60 people with many of them in and out of his area. How do you determine this small town paper is essential?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *