Avatar
All Posts by Empower Wisconsin

Liberty on trial

Empower Wisconsin | May 6, 2020

By M.D. Kittle

MADISON — Liberty versus the unchecked authority of a single government bureaucrat during a public health crisis was on trial Tuesday, as the Wisconsin Supreme Court heard oral arguments in a case challenging the Evers administration’s authority.

The exchanges at times grew heated, as justices grilled attorneys for the Republican-controlled Legislature and the Democrat-led state Department of Justice on whether Wisconsin’s public emergency statutes gave Department of Health Services Secretary-designee Andrea Palm carte blanche power during the pandemic.

“… (W)here in the constitution did the people of Wisconsin confer authority on a single, unelected cabinet secretary to compel almost 6 million people to stay at home and close their businesses and face imprisonment if they don’t comply — with no input from the Legislature, without the consent of the people?” Justice Rebecca Grassl Bradley asked Assistant Attorney General Colin Roth.

The conservative justice broke in after Roth’s opening arguments, declaring that, “In the midst of the deadliest pandemic the world has faced in over a century, the Legislature asks this court to handcuff DHS’ power to combat infectious disease.”

Bradley’s point was clear and direct: do the governed give up their basic constitutional rights to one branch of government because of a health crisis — or any other crisis for that matter?

The lawsuit, Wisconsin Legislature v. Palm, is really about whether the DHS secretary overstepped her statutory authority in extending Gov. Tony Evers’ broad and sweeping stay-at-home orders until May 26 — or indefinitely, depending on the whims of the agency. Ryan Walsh, attorney for the Legislature, argued that DHS does not have the power (after May 10) to cut the Legislature out of the rule-making process. The Legislature, after all, created the Department of Health Services and the other agencies under the executive branch.

“This is the broadest, most sweeping order we know of in Wisconsin history,” he said.

Bradley agreed with her fellow conservatives on the court, who say the constitution is at the core of the case.

The court’s two liberals seem to reject that notion, as does Roth. The assistant AG compared the COVID-19 emergency to a wildfire, insisting that the administration should “do whatever is necessary … to fight it.”

“Isn’t it the very definition of tyranny for one person to order people to be imprisoned for going to work among other ordinarily lawful activities? Where does the constitution say that’s permissible, counsellor?” Bradley asked.

Nope, not tyrannical at all, said Roth, arguing, as he repeatedly did, that the statute allows such actions.

Bradley pointed to another time in history, the U.S. Supreme Court’s Korematsu ruling, that insisted because the need for action was great, “assembling together and placing under guard all those of Japanese ancestry in assembly centers during World War II” was constitutionally permissible. It allowed internment camps. Bradley asked whether Palm’s unilateral authority could lead Wisconsin down that awful road.

“Could the secretary under this broad delegation of legislative power, or legislative-like power order people out of their homes into centers where they are properly social distanced in order to combat the pandemic?” Bradley asked.

The assistant attorney general argued the two cases are different.

Conservative members of the court asked whether there are constitutional or statutory limits on the power of the DHS and its secretary-designee. That sparked one of the more exacting exchanges, in which Justice Daniel Kelly schooled Roth on constitutional law.

Kelly asked whether the DHS lockdown order created criminal penalties for law, an authority only granted the Legislature. Roth finally had to acknowledge that was indeed the case.

“In a sense,” the attorney said. “I don’t know if it’s a material sense.”

“Counsel, I think you might want to think about that a little bit. It’s a really material sense,” Kelly interrupted. “We require standard pre-exists as a matter of law. … The secretary all by herself created a criminal law.”

“Your position is the Secretary can identify behavior that is not otherwise criminal, that she can, all by herself, sit down at her computer keyboard, write up a description of behavior, and make it criminal?” Kelly asked.

“Yes,” the assistant attorney general admitted.

And that’s really the core of a lawsuit that is, on its surface, about whether the Evers administration has illegally bypassed the Legislature’s role in governing. The court’s liberal justices and the assistant attorney general argued the Legislature doesn’t have standing on the constitutional questions of whether the order has hurt Wisconsin businesses and residents.

Another lawsuit filed this week by Wisconsin citizens asks the court to rule on whether the Evers administration and its lockdown have denied civil liberties.

The justices met in closed conference Tuesday afternoon to further discuss the Legislature’s lawsuit.

Even if they issue a swift ruling agreeing with the Legislature, it could be a dozen days at the earliest before the lockdown order is lifted and replaced with a less restrictive pandemic policy.

Listen to more:

Explore More
Tool of the Week: Joe Biden the false ‘unifier’ 

Tool of the Week: Joe Biden the false ‘unifier’ 

Joe Biden infused themes of “unity” throughout his Inaugural speech. Without unity, the new president said, “there is no peace, only bitterness and fury.” 

Read More »

January 25, 2021
4th-grade teacher gives students lesson in Trump-hating

4th-grade teacher gives students lesson in Trump-hating

An Oconto Falls Elementary school teacher told his 4th-grade students that he hopes President Donald Trump will never be president again and that the former president should be “impeached by the Senate,” according to video obtained by Empower Wisconsin.

Read More »

January 25, 2021
Leave it to Evers: Profiles in incompetence

Leave it to Evers: Profiles in incompetence

Need a laugh? Sure, we all could use a chuckle these dark days. The Washington Post … No, that’s not the punchline yet. 

Read More »

January 25, 2021
Evers set to tax small businesses that got COVID loans

Evers set to tax small businesses that got COVID loans

Tax and spend Tony does it again — this time looking to tax the small businesses his administration has driven to the brink of extinction with lockdowns and other COVID-19 health edicts. 

Read More »

January 24, 2021
Kelly: Evers’ extraordinary powers must end

Kelly: Evers’ extraordinary powers must end

Empower Wisconsin | Jan. 22, 2021 By Daniel Kelly, Institute for Reforming Government  History and experience teach us that nothing…

Read More »

January 24, 2021
Bills aim to help fix Evers’ COVID vaccine fiasco

Bills aim to help fix Evers’ COVID vaccine fiasco

Gov. Tony Evers has complained that there isn’t enough supply but federal officials say supply is climbing and vaccine manufacturers are meeting demand — that is the demand of the states’ orders. 

Read More »

January 22, 2021
Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *