Empower Wisconsin
All Posts by Empower Wisconsin

Wall Street Journal Editor: ‘Someone had to speak up’

Empower Wisconsin | Sept. 18, 2019

By M.D. Kittle

MADISON — When word surfaced in October 2013 that prosecutors were expanding their political John Doe investigation to multiple Wisconsin counties, Wall Street Journal editorial writer Collin Levy began to dig around.

It didn’t take long before Levy and her boss, Paul Gigot, Pulitzer Prize-winning editor of the Journal’s Editorial Page, knew they had a powerful story — a story different from what the groupthink press was peddling.

Thanks to Eric O’Keefe, one of scores of conservative activists targeted by partisan prosecutors and Wisconsin’s political speech cops, the newspaper’s editorial board began piecing together the facts. The “John Doe II” was an assault on basic constitutional rights in which investigators illegally raided homes, spied on citizens, and silenced the left’s political opponents. And it was all driven by a bogus campaign finance law theory.

“Eric O’Keefe was willing to go on the record with us, at considerable risk to himself. That’s when we put into work that first editorial,” Gigot told Empower Wisconsin on this week’s Power Up! podcast. (Full disclosure: Eric O’Keefe is president of the Empower Wisconsin Foundation.)

The first piece was headlined, “Wisconsin’s Political Speech Raid,” and, as Gigot said, it blew the lid off the investigation, and exposed coordination theory prosecutors based their secret probe on. “We also had the subpoenas and, bravely, Eric O’Keefe went on the record, risking contempt of court for violating the gag order.”

O’Keefe and his fellow John Doe targets and witnesses faced jail time and hefty fines if they told anyone about the secret investigation.

Wisconsin’s old John Doe procedure, unlike the standard grand jury, was built on silence.

“(In a grand jury,) (Y)ou can speak to the public about what you told the grand jury if you want. You can have a lawyer. You can talk to a lawyer,” Gigot said. “According to targets of this probe, they were told under no uncertain terms, ‘Don’t talk to a lawyer. Don’t talk to anybody about this. Don’t ask anybody else if they were the subjects of the raids. Don’t talk.’”

The gag order made the story that much more compelling. But the tactics used by the prosecutors to target conservative speech never seemed to concern mainstream media outlets like the New York Times and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Gigot said. Nor were most news organizations overly concerned that the campaign finance law theories of state regulators and investigators didn’t match with settled court rulings on political speech.

“In fact, they cheered on the John Doe. The New York Times, the New Yorker, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, they were all in lockstep,” Gigot said.

“The media ought to be, you would think, a protector of the First Amendment and the right to speak, but in this case, they were cheerleaders for reducing political speech,” the editor added. “It was just astounding to me that the rest of the press corps did not show any doubt about what the prosecutors were doing.”

In 2015, the Wisconsin Supreme Court agreed with a lower court decision that quashed the subpoenas used in the probe. The court also declared the investigation unconstitutional and ordered iit shut down for good. John Doe Prosecutors tried to take their bogus theory all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. They lost there, too.

“They had this theory that was a violation of First Amendment and the constitution, yet they used the awesome prosecutorial power of the state to eavesdrop for months on people. (The John Doe targets were) fundraisers, not Gambino Crime Family members. Just people who were trying to raise money to participate in the American democratic process. And they were raided at home at dawn, their children left in tears, they were told they can’t talk, their businesses were forced to shut down, in some cases because they couldn’t raise money anymore in politics.”

“It’s just a tremendous abuse of power in my view. That’s why we stayed on it, that’s why we stayed in it. Someone had to speak up about this because it wasn’t right,” Gigot added.

Paul Gigot, executive editor of the Wall Street Journal Editorial Page, will be the featured speaker at the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL) fall Gala. The event takes place Wednesday, Sept. 18, beginning at 5:30 p.m. at the Italian Community Center, 631 E. Chicago St., Milwaukee. Gigot’s speech is titled, “John Doe: Rogue Prosecutors, Speech Police and Winning! For more information, contact WILL at 414-727-9455, or [email protected]

Listen to more:

Explore More
Kewaunee’s controversial marina scheme

Kewaunee’s controversial marina scheme

Citizens of Kewaunee, Wis., just wanted a relatively inexpensive fix to their flooded-out public marina, a key part of the important recreational fishing industry for this Lake Michigan city of nearly 3,000 residents. 

Read More »

September 23, 2020
Evers extends illegal mask mandate

Evers extends illegal mask mandate

Gov. Tony Evers pushed the bounds of the constitution and state statute again Tuesday, in issuing yet another emergency health order and extending his controversial mask mandate.

Read More »

September 23, 2020
Who funded Kenosha rioters?

Who funded Kenosha rioters?

U.S. Rep. Bryan Steil is calling on U.S. Attorney General Bill Barr to investigate last month’s Kenosha riots; his opponent, Democrat Roger Polack is defending a radical group that, at the very least, appears to have come to Kenosha to aid and abet rioters. 

Read More »

September 23, 2020
Biden botches Pledge of Allegiance

Biden botches Pledge of Allegiance

2020 Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden screwed up the Pledge of Allegiance Monday during a campaign speech in Wisconsin.

Read More »

September 23, 2020
There’s no ‘Biden Rule’ in the constitution

There’s no ‘Biden Rule’ in the constitution

There’s no sugarcoating that the vacancy on the U.S. Supreme Court from the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg comes at a turbulent time in a turbulent year. With emotions running so high, people would be wise to start with the basics of our federal government structure.

Read More »

September 22, 2020
DHS wants 16 percent budget increase

DHS wants 16 percent budget increase

The state agency that led the lockdown of Wisconsin’s citizens and economy is seeking a whopping 16.4 percent increase its 2021-23 budget. 

Read More »

September 22, 2020
Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *