Empower Wisconsin
All Posts by Empower Wisconsin

Watch out: Bill creates big-government retirement savings plan

Empower Wisconsin | Sept. 19, 2019

By M.D. Kittle

MADISON — If you like the government involved in your retirement planning, you’ll love a state Assembly bill being floated.

The legislation creates a state-administered retirement savings plan for employees “of certain private employers” in Wisconsin.

It’s a pilot program, a test plot to see if the state can boost the dismal retirement savings rates of the average worker. The question is, should the state be in that business? In essence, the idea is, You have failed to plan for your future, citizen. Let government take the wheel.

The bill creates more government bureaucracy, establishing a Wisconsin Retirement Savings Board attached to the state Department of Administration. Said board would be “required to establish the savings plan.” Employees — again, private-sector employees — “may contribute” through payroll deductions. They may also opt out. Just like the automatic union dues system, which, of course, has been a huge success for the countless employees who have struggled to escape compulsory payments to Big Labor.

If you’re not sold already, the bill comes with another mandate for small businesses. It would require automatic participation for “certain employers of 25 or more people in this state,” according to the Legislative Reference Bureau.

The Retirement Savings Plan would be managed by third-party investment administrators. Some very special interest would get a very special economic boost — at taxpayers expense.

Proponents say it’s a new twist on the popular 401(k) plan. Except it isn’t. That’s an individual retirement savings plan that employers may offer at their own discretion. Many do — because that’s what the market demands, not the government.

If you think this is just another liberal, big-government proposal, you’d be wrong. The legislation was authored by Assembly Republicans. It is hated by many conservatives, including state Rep. Mary Felzkowski (R-Irma), who calls the legislation “anti-free market.”

“There’s no way this passes. It’s so not a conservative principle,” Felzkowski said. “This is nothing Republicans should ever stand for. We are about the market and competition. This is not anything a true conservative will support.”

The impetus for the bill, according to a recent memo seeking co-sponsors, is the dire state of of retirement savings.

“According to a U.S. Federal Reserve report, roughly one quarter of adults in the United State have little to no retirement savings or pension,” the memo notes. “Of the nearly 25% of the population without these savings, 42% are people between the ages of 18 and 29.”

So why is it the government’s role to ensure working-age people get their savings stuff together?

How about teaching these young non-savers personal finance and personal responsibility, Felzkowski said.

The legislative memo notes that 45 percent of single retirees rely almost exclusively Social Security, accounting for 90 percent of their income. As the bill’s authors point out, Social Security was never intended to replace or be the sole source of retirement income. Social Security’s looming insolvency only makes a bad situation worse. But conservatives say lawmakers ought to learn from the failures of the massive government entitlement program and stay out of the retirement savings business.

Listen to more:

Explore More
Elections Commission still silent on voter fraud cases

Elections Commission still silent on voter fraud cases

Nearly a month after the Wisconsin Elections Commission confirmed it was referring 43 cases of suspected voter fraud for prosecution, the agency has yet to turn over the names of the suspects or the district attorneys handling the cases — information Empower Wisconsin sought through an open records request. 

Read More »

April 7, 2020
GOP Assembly asks Evers to prioritize coronavirus spending

GOP Assembly asks Evers to prioritize coronavirus spending

Gov. Tony Evers is about to have $1.9 billion at his disposal. The Republican-led Legislature would like the Democrat to focus his spending on what Wisconsin really needs to combat the COVID-19 outbreak. 

Read More »

April 7, 2020
A sad fact

A sad fact

President Trump is right. Patients with COVID-19 who require a ventilator face a significantly higher death rate. 

Read More »

April 7, 2020
Evers’ order goes up in smoke

Evers’ order goes up in smoke

In arguably one of the wildest days in Wisconsin election law history, Gov. Tony Evers issued an executive order postponing Wisconsin’s spring election only to have the Wisconsin Supreme Court toss out his edict. 

Read More »

April 7, 2020
All Woke Up: Fat fears in the pandemic

All Woke Up: Fat fears in the pandemic

As the world confronts COVID-19’s mounting death toll and collapsing economy, two University of Wisconsin-La Crosse professors are concerned about “fatphobia.” 

Read More »

April 7, 2020
Not safer at home: A sexual assault victim’s story

Not safer at home: A sexual assault victim’s story

A Milwaukee-area woman worries her daughter, who was sexually assaulted as a child, could be victimized again if the slow-moving state Department of Justice doesn’t act quickly. 

Read More »

April 6, 2020

2 thoughts on “Watch out: Bill creates big-government retirement savings plan

  • The impetus for the bill, according to a recent memo seeking co-sponsors, is the dire state of of retirement savings. (WHEN WISCONSIN POLITICIANS, LEGISLATORS, COURTS AND “ADMINISTRATIVE AGENCIES” as well as DOJ & FBI DENY PROSECUTIONS OF EMBEZZLERS OF RETIREMENT SAVINGS OF 23 CORPORATIONS EMPLOYEES FOR FALCONE’S HEDGE FUND AND GRANT CARL ICAHN STANDING AND SECRECY IN CIVIL SUIT- IT MEANS GOVERNMENT WANTS MORE REVENUE TO EMBEZZLE! ) How dare a Russian blogger expose OUR implied government of ENRON-GATE! How many YEARS can the GOVERNMENT cover up the TRUTH??????? You are ALL SWAMP RATS! The impetus for the bill, according to a recent memo seeking co-sponsors, is the dire state of of retirement savings.

    “According to a U.S. Federal Reserve report, roughly one quarter of adults in the United State have little to no retirement savings or pension,” the memo notes BUT FAILS TO BLAME GOVERNMENT FOR THEIR PART IN ASSET BACKED SECURITIES EMBEZZLEMENT. “Of the nearly 25% of the population without these savings, 42% are people between the ages of 18 and 29.” (NOT ENOUGH TO EMBEZZLE YET, HUH????????)
    https://cycleofstructurednonsense.blogspot.com/2012/12/carl-icahn-sues-philip-falcones.html
    “We” use cookies to ensure that “we” give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site “we will assume” that you are happy with it. Tracking to SILENCE truth tellers is a duty all criminals assume.

  • I seem to remember a few years back when people pre-planned their funerals and paid in advance. If I remember right the funeral homes put that money into a state managed fund that was supposed to increase the value of the original payments in order to cover the inflation. And how did that turn out….the fund value took a dive leaving the paid up funerals under funded. Government cannot ever do a good job of managing any money!

Leave a Reply to Karl A Lurvey Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *